Archive
Posts Tagged ‘nonprofit’
F. Javier Torres, Tim Dorsey and Roberto Bedoya
Have you ever sat at the edge of the pool with a bunch of friends waiting to see who would jump in first?
“Is this the gayest chandelier you ever saw?”
Tim had everyone in the Pavilion Room looking up at a verpitzt lighting fixture hovering heavily above us.
Welcome to Grantmaking with a Racial Equity Lens, a salon session organized by Justin Laing of the Heinz Foundation.
No question, racial equity is a highly charged topic that brings people together with complex emotions simmering beneath their conference badges. No question, we work in a dominant society that is managing our system of race and culture. It is structured racialism, poverty and colonization, all the time.
“We must commit to rootwork. To constantly question powerbrokering.” said Tim. I like that word rootwork. In my mind I imagine deep questioning and determined fistfuls of newer ideas.
Lynn Stern of Surdna described her foundation’s working challenges in supporting “artistic training for young artists, building a training pipeline through college and investing in art colleges committed to outreach and scholarships to targeted populations. There is currently no conversation where a racial equity lens is used. Another question is how to fund small community based organizations. Surdna’s grantmaking mechanism with a budget of $7.5 million has 3 staff members. How can we become familiar with the field? Should we be working with intermediaries?”
Justin Laing
Justin spoke of a racial framework of “your people and you”. This is why culture doesn’t work. He sent a survey that explored whiteness to colleagues and family. There was no response. OK, so I am thinking that whiteness, another highly charged and potentially polarizing topic, cannot be something you ask people to examine without setting up a little context. Blacks have had way more time discussing racial identity.
As Gary Vaynerchuk of VaynerMedia says, “Content is king. Marketing is queen and she rules the house. But context is the heir apparent.”
Clearly we all know the current context and challenges racial equity and social justice pose in our field. Michelle Coffey of the Lambent Foundation suggests “working with critical research partners to help us in our challenge facing race.” She says, “Our concept of race is still dated. We need stronger partners. We are flawed.”
Justin describes a capacity building initiative that identifies young leaders of color by asking the following questions:
- Who are they and what are they doing?
- What is the logic model, the scorecard, the projected impact?
- What resources do they need?
- What about people with disabilities?
- What is their branding, messaging, communications plan?
- Is there a dashboard with quarterly benchmarks for assessment?
- Do they have a strong board?
- What is their fundraising plan?
Huong Vo of Boeing raised the question of individual strategy.
“Don’t you get tired of being the one who has to be indignant about racism just because you are the person of color on staff?”
There is always the spectre of consequences and repercussions – financial, emotional, psychological – when you challenge an unacceptable statement or action, when we summon up personal courage to own our actions.
Perhaps there are other ways to work with colleagues and board members such as challenging imagery that portray white people as donors and privileged, and people of color as receivers and less fortunate.
We need to speak as a group more often, more knowledgeably.
So come on in, the water’s fine.
About the Author: Hoong Yee Lee Krakauer writes about how to be a nimble nonprofit, make life creative and make a difference at www.hoongyee.com.
She is also the Executive Director of the Queens Council on the Arts. Hoong Yee can be found surfing in the Rockaways whenever there are waves.
Do you want to know the fears, visions of perfect worlds and world changing advice of your peers and keynote speakers?
I have a special bonus post for you of interviews I conducted with people during the conference. Just leave me a comment with your email or better still, subscribe at www.hoongyee.com and get my interview post and new style notes for people who change the world delivered to your inbox.
Is There More To Life Than Donuts And Bingo?
Tim Carpenter
Tim Carpenter does.
Tim, the radio host of Experience Talks and the 2011 Winner of the James Irvine Leadership Award, also believes there must be more for people than bingo and donuts in their later years. He tells the story, of course he does – he comes from an Irish Catholic family where storytelling was a competitive sport. The older people told better stories so he sat at that end of the dinner table.
“Retirement is like college. It is a launching period. Free time. Time to ask yourself, ‘OK, what do I do now?‘”
Tim grinned at his co conversationalist, Mark Freedman, the author of Encore: Finding Work That Matters In The Second Half Of Life at a session organized by Rohit Burman entitled The Big Shift: The Velocity Of Change In America’s Aging Society.
Rohit Burman
“An acre of time.” I love that phrase.
What would you put in this acre of time?
They spoke about developing buildings around programs that get people out doing stuff. Including college level programs and workforce development for artists, building an artist colony. Asking the question – what if you could live here among artists?
Marc Freedman
“Age is a time to bloom, a time of great fertility. A time to celebrate their best work when they are ‘over the hill’. People think genius happens early in life but actually many artists were late bloomers such as Cezanne. Priorities are affected by the sense of mortality which people experience as a compression of time, a heightened sense of time left to live. Relationships deepen, spirituality attracts. ” said Marc. ”It is the trifecta of mortality, longevity and urgency.”
“The process of becoming something is more interesting.” Tim said. ”Suzanne, a woman in her mid 60′s, single mom with 2 kids, was ‘old before her time‘. She attended my writing class and wrote a 12 page screenplay about the challenges and needs of aging called Bandida. I remember thinking to myself ‘please don’t stink’. But it was good. And we made it into a film that was eventually shown by Ira Glass on This American Life.
This answers the question ‘Where does funding have impact?’ Suzanne is a new person, a mentor and teacher to others. This is why we need optimism, something Marc often speaks of.”
Marc shook his head. ”I worry that we feed the notion of magical reinvention, that there is a genius inside waiting to pop out. What is a more realistic vision for us? Perhaps a reintegration of preexisting goals and ideas, more an extension of what you already are.”
“There is a need for arts in the schools to build these skills early, to get art experiences and to connect older artists with kids,” said Tim.
“What about that gap year we have at 18 and 19? What if we had a disruptive creative period of time in our 50′s. It could be a period of renewal focused on the arts. Could we build in a leap year, a gap year. In the UK, 200,00 people are grey gappers.” Marc smiled. ”You could have an encore career, a second career after 50.”
“How do you get one of those?” asked Tim.
Marc said, “We need the arts to give a realistic vision to this new phase of life. There is a lack of focus on this time. There is a second group between midlife and elderly old age with no arts avenue. Their challenge is to reimagine the shape of living.”
They closed with this:
“60 is the new 60. Live your legacy.”
About the Author: Hoong Yee Lee Krakauer writes about how to be a nimble nonprofit, make life creative and make a difference at www.hoongyee.com.
She is also the Executive Director of the Queens Council on the Arts. Hoong Yee can be found surfing in the Rockaways whenever there are waves.
Do you want to know the fears, visions of perfect worlds and world changing advice of your peers and keynote speakers?
I have a special bonus post for you of interviews I conducted with people during the conference. Just leave me a comment with your email or better still, subscribe at www.hoongyee.com and get my interview post and new style notes for people who change the world delivered to your inbox.
Marc Bamuthi Joseph
How do you listen to a whirlwind?
If the whirlwind has a name, such as Marc Bamuthi Joseph, and he is before you – natty, smart, hey let me check you out stylish with a sharp lid tossed casually to the side as he picks up speed and lets the words fly -
- you sit back. Now.
As a conference blogger, I sat at Marc’s Keynote Performance at the Plenary Breakfast Session on Monday at the Grantmakers for the Arts 2011 Conference, confident in capturing the essence of the experience while having my morning coffee with a ballroom full of my colleagues.
It became very clear that Marc operates at speeds unfamiliar to most people and I was left both delighted and bewildered by his message.
So in the spirit of capturing the wind, here is what I caught from that performance:
If you can’t outrun it, get out in front of it and figure out where we’re going
Let’s transform the iconography of an environment
Practice the art of believing that these things, dance, buildings, art, have redemptive quality
Here’s a recipe for a creative ecosystem of critical adjacencies -
Take equal parts revenue potential, artistic presence and invested audience consistency.
Mix well.
Let rise.
Voila! A localized interdisiplinary network.
No amount of Facebook contact can compete with public proximity and investment
Art happens everywhere for anyone
Art is not and object or an outcome only
Art is a process and an opportunity for community
It is hard for grantmakers to track outcomes and creative stimulus but perhaps we should be looking at metrics to measure the scale and health of creative partnerships in our ecosystems
Success is tied to the growth of others
Good changes in structure focus on interdependence, not products
Invest in artists who create contextual work within communities
Let’s shift nonprofit practice and structure to value accumulated surpluses
Formula for changing the world -
Audience development + good fiscal health = healthy arts field
Whew! If you want to get closer to the wind and get more of Marc, check out http://www.lifeisliving.org/
Let me leave you with my favorite piece of current wisdom from Marc:
If you can’t outrun it, get out in front of it and figure out where it’s going.
About the Author: Hoong Yee Lee Krakauer writes about how to be a nimble nonprofit, make life creative and make a difference at www.hoongyee.com.
She is also the Executive Director of the Queens Council on the Arts. Hoong Yee can be found surfing in the Rockaways whenever there are waves.
Do you want to know the fears, visions of perfect worlds and world changing advice of your peers and keynote speakers? I have a special bonus post for you of interviews I conducted with people during the conference. Just leave me a comment with your email or better still, subscribe and get new style notes for people who change the world at www.hoongyee.com.
“You would really enjoy it, and you will meet lots of fabulous people – like you – doing great work,” June tossed back her hair and waved her fork in the air at the little Greek restaurant in Forest Hills where we often have lunch.
The compliment was really not a compliment but code for an invitation to attend the Beautiful Foundation USA’s 4th Seed of Giving Conference with her, to meet some of the people she tells me about, and to find out a little more of what is going on in this particular universe. ”You meet, you eat.”
June and her gift of synopsis. How could I not go?
Good question.
But unlike many great questions that will hover like unanswered mysteries during our brief sparklike lifetimes such as what is the meaning of life, there are some puzzling enigmas that, under the bright klieg light of research and data, are startled into revealing their answers.
One question caught my attention at the conference and I listened intently to the panel of speakers, searching for answers.
The question is:
How can shopping and drinking change the world?
You may be thinking that personal vices are hardly worth more than a disgusted snort and airy dismissal but I am a big believer in being open to opportunities and certainly after Hali Lee of AWGC, the Asian Women Giving Circle, talked about how they invest in change as “philanthropy virgins” who can become future philanthropists, board members and engaged civic citizens who like to shop and drink, well, I could hardly keep from jumping up and down from joy.
Picture this. A small committee whose members:
- contribute $2500 to a pot of money that is granted out to AAW, Asian American women, who use the arts to further their activism
- increase the visibility of AAW doing philanthropy
- educate donors by voting during grantee selection
- and as Wayne Ho of CACF, Coalition for Asian American Children and Families, mischievously pointed out, “Did everyone notice Hali mentioned drinking three times?”
Yes, they have a lot of fun shopping, drinking, raising dollars and yes, this is how they are changing the world.
Every field, every self-defined group has their leaders. The more successful ones also have advocates, a growing awareness of what work needs to be done and most importantly, a lot of people who are not shy about making some noise about what they need.
I was impressed by the eagerness of this crowd to ask pointed questions and agree passionately with keynote speaker Peggy Saiko of AAPIP, the Asian Americans/Pacific Islanders in Philanthropy, who said, ”I prefer framing our work as ‘enduring challenges’ rather than ‘institutional racism’”.
How do you even begin?
Here are four questions Peggy asked to jumpstart our collective thinking:
1. Why are there such low numbers of API on foundations, boards and higher positions of decision making?
2. Why are there no overarching strategies in philanthropic support to the API community?
3. Why does the API community continue to remain invisible and in need during times of crisis?
Peggy says that current data shows that philanthropy could be doing more in supporting a “democracy of distinct communities”. Last I heard, a very large number of foundations target distinct and diverse communities as funding priorities. Do you think it is possible that we, the “model minority” have become more than invisible? Do you think we are now, white? What is the best way to transform our message from “invisible” to “inevitable”?
4. How can we be better at arguing and advocating for presence at the table and in decision making roles?
Can I say something here?
I consider myself part of the Asian American community, OK, I married a nice Jewish guy but that doesn’t change my gene pool. I am immersed in emerging and diverse communities. I work in Queens for crying out loud and you cannot avoid running into a huddled mass anywhere in this borough. But I was slightly bewildered by the acronyms and the shorthand speak of this group. Like most people, I like to know what everyone is talking about, especially when I am the newcomer.
API stands for Asian/Pacific Islander. APA stands for Asian Pacific American. I suppose if I read the stuff in my folder this would be a non-issue. My bad.
How can we expect people new to us to feel part of what we do if our message is jargon heavy. Clarity, at all times. You never know who may be listening and not reading.
Just a thought.
And another great phrase, “the culture of shame”! Is this what stops people from talking about their needs publicly? Does the need to save face make us lose the opportunity to heal?
Another question Peggy answered was, “Are there too many nonprofits?” Could this possibly be the reason such a low percentage of support trickles down to API?
“Lucy Bernholz asks the better question, which is,” she exclaimed passionately. ”do we have the right set of groups who can deliver the services and goods our community needs? Here is where investments must be made to sustain the just society that belongs to all of us.”
Back to enduring challenges. AAPIP decided to become grantmakers to mobilize investments in “cultural competency” and to nurture “signs of hope”.
The story of their fourteen giving circles on grass root levels is a lovely sign of hope.
“These circles are not just about fundraising. It is a way for people to understand the field and how it is structured.” And shop and drink, I was glad to hear.
A Beautiful Story
“In their first year of existence, the Los Angeles giving circle of Korean American women emptied their closets, held a street sale, inspired a noted Korean golfer to write them a check for $10k and a local restauranteur to donate $2,500. AAPIP contributed a 50% match helping the circle in raising $32k in total for an evening of having fun and, taking care of each other.”
Peggy paused for a moment.
“It is so true what they say about beauty,” I thought to myself with a smile growing inside my soul. ”Beauty is rarely skin deep.”
What do you think is the best way to change the world?
Do we need more data, more stories?
What about more “cultural assets” to move our faces into the mainstream of buzz?
I have a few ideas. Tell me yours.
Ben Flanner and his cool parents
Dinner and a movie on the roof
Are vegetables good for you?
Of course!
Are they fun?
Fun? And cool.
Here at the SMP Building in Long Island City, up on the roof, Ben Flanner has created a one acre farm with a killer view. Ben has always wanted to run a farm, according to his mom. I don’t know if he ever imagined that farm to be on top of a former auto parts manufacturing building on Northern Boulevard but that’ s what makes his farm so cool.
We had a dinner for about fifty people followed by a screening of one minute videos created by local artists in their favorite restaurants in Queens.
This is a little film project we call the Moveable Feast. Do you want a peek at where artists like to eat? Check these out.
We had salad with greens from the farm and desserts made by aspiring pastry chefs from the food incubator program down the block. I nibbled on beet greens which are a beautiful deep red color and delicious in a mixed green salad.
Locals Rule
I love being a local.
I love buying local produce, working with local artists, supporting local businesses. There is an unmistakeable sense of pride that is part and parcel of local creative industries. It is a distinctive Queens edge that comes through.
Especially in the lettuce.
Get more Wow!
If you want style notes and more for people who change the world, please check out:
Getting to Wow! to feel good, do good and look good
Nonprofit Knitwear for all things knit and nonprofit
Style Notes from me, your artspy
Hoong Yee
– Subscribe and get a little Wow! every day
– Forward the link to someone you think would be interested
– Link to a post on Twitter (follow me @hylkrakauer)
– Put a link to the blog in your Facebook status update
Thanks so much! I really appreciate your help.
Word of mouth is the best way to share, don’t you agree?
I write for love and money. It is my everyday passion. What's yours? 
